I recently built "seminar" as somewhat of an experiment ( https:// github.com/hgrsd/seminar ). I wanted to see if letting LLMs, with access to tools like web se
A developer experimented with an AI system called "seminar" designed to generate a body of studies based on ambiguous ideas, with LLMs accessing tools like web search and PDF reading. While the system provided interesting reading material and encouraged the user's own thinking, it failed to produce novel insights or synthesize existing studies into new research ideas. The AI's attempts at generating new concepts were often outlandish and pompously presented, leading the developer to conclude it's not yet suitable for serious use but can serve as a starting point for human thought. AI
IMPACT Demonstrates current limitations of LLMs in generating novel research ideas, highlighting their utility as a starting point for human creativity rather than independent discovery.